2016

Set out below are decisions handed down by the Football NSW General Purposes Tribunal and Appeals Tribunal (Tribunals).

Section 12.18 of the Football NSW Grievance and Disciplinary Regulations (adopted on 21 February 2013) allows Football NSW to disclose decisions of the Tribunals on its website subject to any confidentiality or any other legal requirements.

By electronically disseminating the decisions, Tribunals can better educate the football community about certain conduct, make precedent-setting decisions readily accessible, promote transparency and demonstrate accountability.

 

MGPT

Reference/Party

Charge

Keywords

Outcome

MGPT 16-01

(23/03/16)

Fabio MACEROLA

Blacktown Spartans FC

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

2. Expelled from the field of play, had contact with a Match Official within one hour after the conclusion of the match (section 16.6(f)(iii)(C))

 

Coach

Abusive Language

 

 

 

1. Guilty
(Suspension 3 fixtures)

2. Received a reprimand

MGPT 16-02

(30/03/16)

Harry PARASKEVAIDIS

Sydney Olympic

 

Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

 

Coach

Guilty Plea

Abusive Language

 

Guilty. (Suspension 3 fixtures)

MGPT 16-03

(22-04-2016)

Stephen FINCH

Spirit FC

 

Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

 

Must not, for the remainder of the Match, enter the Field of Play, its surrounds or the Technical Area or occupy the Player's race, if applicable (Section 16.6(f)(iii))

Coach

Abusive language

Fail to leave Technical Area

Guilty

Guilty (Suspension 7-fixtures)

MGPT 16-04

(30/03/16)

Steve APPLEBY

Mt Druitt Town Rangers

Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

Coach

Guilty Plea

Abusive Language

Expulsion Offence

Guilty. (Suspension 3 fixtures)

MGPT 16-05

(20/04/16)

James BECERRA

Fraser Park FC

Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

Coach

Abusive Language

 

Guilty. (Suspension 2 fixtures)

MGPT 16-06

(02/05/16)

Michael MILETO

Nepean FC

Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

Coach

Insulting Language

 

Guilty.
(Suspension 3 fixtures)

MGPT 16-07

(20/04/16)

Sevan HANIMYAN

Balmain Tigers FC

Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

Coach

Expelled

Abusive Language

Guilty Plea

 

Guilty. 
(Suspension 3 fixtures)

MGPT 16-08

(20/04/16)

Peter TSEKENSI

St George FC

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

2. Threatening or intimidating language or conduct towards a Match Official (Schedule 3, Table B, Number 5)

 

Coach

Expelled

Abusive Language

Guilty Plea

1. Guilty 
(Suspension 3 fixtures)

2. Not guilty

MGPT 16-09

(21/04/16)

Will CULLEN

Dunbar Rovers

Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

Coach

Expelled

Abusive Language

 

Guilty.
(Suspension 6 fixtures)

MGPT 16-10

(21/04/2016)

George GANIATSAS

Gladesville Ryde Magic FC

Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

Coach

Expelled

Offensive Language

Match Official

History

Guilty

(Suspension 9 fixtures)

MGPT 16-11

(21/04/16)

George SIDIS

APIA Leichhardt Tigers

Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

Coach

Expelled

Abusive Language

Guilty. 
(Suspension 3 fixtures)

MGPT 16-12

(05/05/16)

Darren GEANY

Bankstown United

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

2. (a) Threatening or intimidating language or conduct towards a Match Official (Schedule 3, Table B, Number 5)

(b) Unsportsmanlike or unprofessional behavior (Schedule 3: Table C, Number 7)

Coach

Offensive Language

Unprofessional

Entering Referees Room

 

1. Guilty
(Suspension 4 fixtures)

2. Guilty.
(Suspension 5 fixtures)

(suspension served concurrently)

MGPT 16-13

(05/05/16)

Gwynne BERRY

Manly United

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

2. Expelled from the field of play, had contact with a Match Official within one hour after the conclusion of the match (section 16.6(f)(iii)(C))

Coach

Expelled

Abusive Language

Re-approached Match Officials

 

1. Guilty
(Suspension 5 fixtures)

2. Guilty.
(Suspension 1 fixture)

(Total 6 fixtures)

MGPT 16-14

(12/05/16)

Jason NAJDOVSKI

Rockdale City Suns FC

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

2. Unsportsmanlike or unprofessional behavior (Schedule 3: Table C, Number 7)

Coach

Aggressive

Abusive Language

 

 

1. Guilty.
(Suspension 3 fixtures)

2. Guilty.
(Suspension 4 fixtures)

(Discount of 2 fixtures, suspended for total of 5 fixtures)

MGPT 16-15

(19/05/2016)

Blaze STEVANOVSKI

Rockdale City Suns FC

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

Coach

Unprofessional

Offensive Language

Match Officials

1. Guilty

(Suspension 4 fixtures)

(Discount of 1 fixture, early guilty plea, suspended for total of 3 fixtures)

MGPT 16-16

(19/05/2016)

Eddie HARAGLI

Stanmore Hawks FC

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

Coach

Aggressive

Offensive Language

1. Guilty

(Suspension 3 fixtures from all football activities)

MGPT 16-17

(19/05/2016)

Andrew Casali

Balmain Tigers FC

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

Coach

Swearing at Match Official

1. Guilty

(Suspension 3 fixtures from all football activities)

MGPT 16-18

(12/05/2016)

Ryan Whitlam

Glebe Gorillas

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

2. Unsportsmanlike or unprofessional behavior (Schedule 3: Table C, Number 7)

R7

Refusing to leave Field of Play

Offensive Language to Match Official

1. Guilty 

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

2. Guilty

(Suspension of 4 fixtures)

(Received discount of 2 fixtures for early guilty plea, total suspension of 5 fixtures)

MGPT 16-20

(17 May 2016)

Brian Brown

Bonnyrigg White Eagles FC

 

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

2. Expelled from the field of play, had contact with a Match Official within one hour after the conclusion of the match (section 16.6(f)(iii)(C))

Offensive language

Insulting language

Expelled

Approach Match Official after Match

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

2. Guilty

(Suspension of 2 fixtures)

(suspension served concurrently)

MGPT 16-21

(24 May 2016)

Ivo De Jesus

St George FC

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

Offensive language

Red Card

 

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

MGPT 16-22

(24/05/2016)

Paulo Oliveira

Fraser Park FC

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

Offensive language

Expelled

 

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

MGPT 16-23

(24/05/2016)

Mr TREX

Manly United FC

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

R7

Offensive language towards Match Official after R7

1. Guilty 

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

MGPT 16-24

(02/06/2016)

Frank Barbaro

Parramatta FC

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

2.Failure to follow any reasonable direction of an Official or Football NSW employee or representative in relation to conduct and/or behaviour at a Match (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 5)

Coach

Expulsion

Offensive language

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

2. Guilty

(Suspension of 2 fixtures)

(Suspension of 5 fixtures, 1 already served and suspension includes all football activities)

MGPT 16-24

(02/06/2016)

Mr TYOX

Parramatta FC

1. R1 - Serious Foul Play

2. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

Player

R1

Offensive language towards Match Official after Red Card

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 2 fixtures)

2. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

(Suspension of 5 fixtures, 1 already served and suspension includes all football activities)

MGPT 16-25

(02/06/2016)

Geoff Gidney

Southern Shire Football

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

Coach

Offensive language towards Match Official

Expelled

Insulting language

1. Guilty 

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

Suspended from all football activities

MGPT 16-26

(31/05/2016)

Adam Scimone

Western NSW Mariners FC

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

2.Failure to follow any reasonable direction of an Official or Football NSW employee or representative in relation to conduct and/or behaviour at a Match (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 5)

3. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

Coach

Offensive language towards Match Official

Failed to leave Technical Area

Insulting language

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

2. Guilty

(Suspension of 2 fixtures)

3. Guilty

(Suspension of 1 fixtures)

 

(Total suspension of 5 fixtures)

MGPT 16-27

(31/05/2016)

Steve Cowley

Illawarra Stingrays

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

Offensive language towards Match Official

1. Not Guilty

MGPT 16-28

(02/06/2016)

Steve Hurd

Northern Tigers

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

Coach

Offensive language towards Match Official

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

MGPT 16-29

(14/06/2016)

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

2. Unsportsmanlike or unprofessional behavior (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table C, Number 7)

Player

Offensive language towards Match Official

Unsportsmanlike behavior 

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

2. Guilty

(Suspension of 4 fixtures)

MGPT 16-30

(21/06/2016)

Arthur Alepedis

Fraser Park FC

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

Coach

Offensive language towards Match Official

Expelled from Technical Area

1. Not Guilty

MGPT 16-31

(20/06/2016)

 

1. Serious foul play (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table A, Number 1)

Player

Serious foul play

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 6 fixtures)

MGPT 16-32

(23/06/2016)

Scott Gilligan

East Coast Heat FC

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

Offensive language towards Match Official

 

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

MGPT 16-34

(23/06/2016)

Richard Artesi

Southern District Raiders

 

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

2. Failure to follow reasonable direction of an official (Section 15.4(d) Schedule 3, Table C, Number 8)

Coach

Offensive language towards Match Official

Failure to follow direction of an Official

1. Not Guilty

2. Not Guilty

MGPT 16-35

(30/06/2016)

Michael Grbevski

Rockdale City Suns

1. Threatening or intimidating language or conduct towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 5)

2. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

Coach

Offensive language towards Match Official

Threatening or intimidating language/conduct

1. Not Guilty

2. Guilty

(Suspension of 4 fixtures)

MGPT 16-36

(07/07/2016)

John Avouris

Wollongong Wolves

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

Coach

Offensive language towards Match Official

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 5 fixtures, discount of two fixtures, total 3 fixtures)

MGPT 16-38

(06/06/2016)

Ivo De Jesus

St George FC

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

Coach

Offensive language towards Match Official

1. Not Guilty

MGPT 16-38

(06/06/2016)

Nassareo Martino

St George FC

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

Coach

Offensive language towards Match Official

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 4 fixtures)

MGPT 16-40

(06/06/2016)

Mirjan Pavlovic

Marconi Stallions

1. Use of discriminatory, homophobic, racist, religious, ethnic or sexist language (Section 15.4(d) Schedule 3, Table B, Number 4)

Player

 

1. Not Guilty

MGPT 16-41

(07/07/2016)

Stacy Alogdellis

Sydney Olympic FC

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

Coach

Offensive language towards Match Official

Sent from Technical Area

 

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 5 fixtures)

MGPT 16-42

(30/06/2016)

Jacob Timpano

Wollongong Wolves

 

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

2. Unsportsmanlike or unprofessional behavior (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table C, Number 7)

Coach

Offensive language towards Match Official 

Unsportsmanlike behavior

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

2. Guilty

(Suspension of 4 fixtures)

Served concurrently

MGPT 16-43

Darren McDonald

Kirrawee Kangaroos FC

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

 

Player

Offensive language towards Match Official

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

MGPT 16-45

(21/07/2016)

Marshall Soper

Gladesville Ryde Magic

1. Not wearing eligibilty card as a team official in the technical area (Section 15.4(e), Section 2, Sub-section 6(b))

2. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

Coach

Eligibilty card

Offensive language towards Match Official

1. Guilty

(Warning/reprimand)

2. Not Guilty

MGPT 16-46

Ivan Galic

Bankstown City Lions FC

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

2. Threatening language or intimidating language or conduct towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d) Schedule 3, Table B, Number 5)

3. Failure to follow reasonable direction of an Official (Section 15.4(d) Schedule 3, Table C, Number 8)

Coach

Offensive language towards Match Official

Threatening/intimidating language

Failure to follow reasonable direction of an Official

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

2. Guilty

(Suspension of 12 fixtures)

3. Guilty

(Suspension of 2 fixtures)

(Charge 1 & 2 to be served concurrently, total of 14 fixtures)

MGPT 16-47

(02/08/2016)

Nestor Moreno

UNSW FC

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

Coach

Offensive language towards Match Official

 

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 4 fixtures)

MGPT 16-48

(17/07/2016)

Miguel Quineche

Nepean FC

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

2. Failure to follow reasonable direction of an Official (Section 15.4(d) Schedule 3, Table C, Number 8)

3. Entering the field of play without authorisation (Schedule 3, Table C, Number 9)

Coach

Technical Area

Entering Field of Play

1. Not guilty

2. Not guilty

3. Guilty

(Suspension of 2 fixtures)

MGPT 16-50

(24/07/2016)

Albert Disciascio

Bankstown City Lions FC

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

2. Failure to follow reasonable direction of an Official (Section 15.4(d) Schedule 3, Table C, Number 8)

Coach

Offensive language towards Match Official

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

2. Guilty

(Suspension of 2 fixtures)

MGPT 16-51

(30/07/2016)

Reece Iredale

Prospect United SC

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

2. Failure to follow reasonable direction of an Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table C, Number 8)

Offensive language towards Match Official

Player

1. Not guilty

2. Not guilty

MGPT 16-53

(28/07/2016)

Shane Duffy

Marconi Stallions FC

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

Coach

Offensive language towards Match Official

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 6 fixtures)

MGPT 16-55

(06/08/2016)

Nathan Byrn

Central Coast Mariners FC

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

Coach

Offensive language towards Match Official

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

MGPT 16-56

(15/09/2016)

Grant Lee

Sydney Olympic FC

 

1. Threatening or intimidating language or conduct towards a Match Official (section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 5)

and/or

Failure to follow any reasonable direction of an Official or Football NSW employee or representative in relation to conduct and/or behavior at a Match in breach of section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table C, Number 8).

 Coach

Threatening or intimidating language or conduct towards a Match Official

Failure to follow any reasonable direction of an Official or Football NSW employee

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 2 fixtures)

MGPT 16-57

(22/08/2016)

Vic ZAPPIA

Granville Rage

1. Offensive, insulting abusive language and/or gestures towards or about a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

Team Official

Offensive language towards a Match Official 

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

MGPT 16-58

(25/08/2016)

Daniel VELLONIO

Inner West Magic

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards or about a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Scedule 3. Table B, Number 1)

Spectator

Offensive language towards a Match Official

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 6 fixtures)

MGPT 16-59

(20/08/2016)

Jacqui BACHELARD

Northern Tigers FC

1. Failure to follow reasonable direction from an Official or Football NSW Employee or representative in relation to conduct and/or behaviour at a Match (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table C, Number 8)

Team Official 

Failure to follow any reasonable direction of an Official or Football NSW Employee

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 2 fixtures)

MGPT 16-60

(01/09/2016)

Stelianos GEORGIOU

Balmain Tigers FC

1. Failure to follow reasonable direction from an Official or Football NSW Employee or representative in relation to conduct and/or behaviour at a Match (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table C, Number 8)

Coach

Failure to follow any reasonable direction of an Official or Football NSW Employee

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

MGPT 16-61

(26/08/2016)

Ognjen MATIC

Macarthur Rams FC

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards or about a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3. Table B, Number 1)

Coach

Offensive language towards a Match Official

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

MGPT 16-62

(24/08/2016)

South Brisbane FC

Jade BAKER

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards or about a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3. Table B, Number 1)

2. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards or about a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3. Table B, Number 1)

Player

Offensive language towards a Match Official

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

2. Guilty 

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

MGPT 16-63

(06/09/2016)

Joe PACCHIAROTTA

SD Raiders FC

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards or about a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3. Table B, Number 1)

Coach

Offensive language towards a Match Official

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

MGPT 16-65

(06/09/2016)

Chris CAMILLERI

Rydalmere Lions FC

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards or about a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3. Table B, Number 1)

2. Threatening or intimidating language or conduct towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 5)

3. Failure to follow any reasonable direction of an Official or Football NSW Employee or representative in relation to conduct and/or behaviour at a Match (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table C, Number 8)

Coach

Offensive language towards a Match Official

Threatening or intimidating language or conduct towards a Match Official

Failure to follow any reasonable direction of an Official or Football NSW Employee

 

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

2. Not guilty

3. Guilty

(Suspension of 2 fixtures)

MGPT 16-66

(13/09/2016)

Eddie HARAGLI

Stanmore Hawkes

1. Failure to follow any reasonable direction of an Official or Football NSW Employee or representative in relation to conduct and/or behaviour at a Match (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table C, Number 8)

2. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards or about a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3. Table B, Number 1)

Coach

Failure to follow any reasonable direction of an Official or Football NSW Employee

Offensive language towards a Match Official

1. Not guilty

2. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

MGPT 16-67

(14/09/2016)

Andrew PRENTICE

Sydney University SFC

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards or about a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3. Table B, Number 1)

2. Threatening or intimidating language or conduct towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 5); and/or

Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards or about a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3. Table B, Number 1)

3. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards or about a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3. Table B, Number 1)

Coach

Offensive language towards a Match Official

Threatening or intimidating language or conduct towards a Match Official

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

2. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

3. Guilty 

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

MGPT 16-68

(27/09/2016)

Nubia LOPEZ

Mount Druitt Town Rangers

1. Red Card for hitting a player (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table A; 'R2 Violent Conduct - Punching')

2. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards or about a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3. Table B, Number 1)

3. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards or about a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3. Table B, Number 1)

Player

Violent Conduct

Offensive language towards a Match Official

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

2. Not guilty

3. Not guilty

MGPT 16-69

(16/09/2016)

Jeffery ARKHIOM

SD Raiders FC

1. Failure to follow any reasonable direction of an Official or Football NSW Employee or representative in relation to conduct and/or behaviour at a Match (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table C, Number 8)

Coach

Failure to follow any reasonable direction of an Official or Football NSW Employee

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 2 fixtures)

MGPT 16-71

(03/11/2016)

Daivd BERTRAM

Balmain Tigers FC

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards or about a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3. Table B, Number 1)

2. Failure to follow any reasonable direction of an Official or Football NSW Employee or representative in relation to conduct and/or behaviour at a Match (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table C, Number 8)

3. Threatening or intimidating language or conduct towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 5)

Coach 

Offensive language towards a Match Official

Failure to follow any reasonable direction of an Official or Football NSW Employee

Threatening or intimidating language or conduct towards a Match Official

1. Guilty 

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

2. Not guilty

3. Not guilty

MGPT 16-73

(23/09/2016)

Manny SPANOUDAKIS

St George FC

1. Unsportsmanlike or unprofessional behaviour (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table C, Number 1)

2. Failure to follow any reasonable direction of an Official or Football NSW Employee or representative in relation to conduct and/or behaviour at a Match (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table C, Number 8)

3. Entering the Field of Play after being expelled from the technical area (Section 15.4(d), Schedule, Table C, Number 9)

Coach

Unprofessional 

Failure to follow any reasonable direction of an Official or Football NSW Employee

Expelled

 

1. Guilty

(Suspension of four fixtures)

2. Guilty

(Suspension of 2 fixtures)

3. Guilty

(Suspension of 2 fixtures)

MGPT 16-74

(06/10/2016)

Aytek GENC

St George FC

1. Unsportsmanlike or unprofessional behaviour (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table C, Number 1)

2. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards or about a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3. Table B, Number 1)

Team Official 

Unprofessional

Offensive language towards a Match Official

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 4 fixtures)

2. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

 

MGPT 16-75

(04/10/2016)

Shaun BORTHWICK

Penrith Rovers FC

1. Red Card for using offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards or about a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

2. Threatening or intimidating language or conduct towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 5)

3. Threatening or intimidating language or conduct towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 5)

Player

Red Card

Offensive language towards a Match Official

Threatening or intimidating language or conduct towards a Match Official

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

2. Guilty

(Suspension of 12 fixtures)

Guilty

(Suspension of 12 fixtures)

MGPT 16-76

(04/10/2016)

Thomas SERRATORE

Connells Point Rovers FC

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards or about a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3. Table B, Number 1)

Coach

Offensive language towards a Match Official

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

MGPT 16-76

(04/10/2016)

John RODAS

Connells Point Rovers FC

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards or about a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3. Table B, Number 1)

Team Official

Offensive language towards a Match Official

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

MGPT 16-78

(17/10/2016)

Bradley Hill

Mt Pritchard Junior Soccer Club

1. Failure to follow any reasonable direction of an Official or Football NSW Employee or representative in relation to conduct and/or behaviour at a Match (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table C, Number 8)

Coach

Failure to follow any reasonable direction of an Official or Football NSW Employee

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 2 fixtures)

MGPT 16-78

(17/10/2016)

Rodney LUKE

Mt Pritchard Junior Soccer Club

1. Failure to follow any reasonable direction of an Official or Football NSW Employee or representative in relation to conduct and/or behaviour at a Match (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table C, Number 8)

Coach 

Failure to follow any reasonable direction of an Official or Football NSW Employee

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 2 fixtures)

MGPT 16-79

(19/10/2016)

Melanie McCAULEY

Campbelltown Quake FC

 

1. Failure to follow any reasonable direction of an Official or Football NSW Employee or representative in relation to conduct and/or behaviour at a Match (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table C, Number 8)

Coach 

Failure to follow any reasonable direction of an Official or Football NSW Employee

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 2 fixtures)

MGPT 16-80

(27/10/2016)

Dylan FULLER

Central Coast Futsal Club

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards or about a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3. Table B, Number 1)

Player

Offensive language towards a Match Official

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

MGPT 16-81

(24/10/2016)

Ludo STAETEMAN

Narrabeen FC

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards or about a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3. Table B, Number 1)

Team Official

Offensive language towards a Match Official

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

MGPT 16-82

(22/11/2016)

Zohier BELKADI

Central Coast Futsal Club

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards or about a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3. Table B, Number 1); and/or

Unsportsmanlike or unprofessional behaviour (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table C, Number 7)

2. Unsportsmanlike or unprofessional behaviour (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table C, Number 7)

3. Failure to follow any reasonable direction of an Official or Football NSW Employee or representative in relation to conduct and/or behaviour at a Match (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table C, Number 8)

Coach

Offensive language towards a Match Official

Unprofessional

Failure to follow any reasonable direction of an Official or Football NSW Employee

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

2. Guilty

(Suspension of 4 fixtures)

3. Guilty

(Suspension of 2 fixtures)

MGPT 16-83

(29/11/2016)

Cristian BERRIOS

Phoenix Futsal Club 

1. Failure to follow any reasonable direction of an Official or Football NSW Employee or representative in relation to conduct and/or behaviour at a Match (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table C, Number 8)

2. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards or about a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3. Table B, Number 1)

Coach

Failure to follow any reasonable direction of an Official or Football NSW Employee

Offensive language towards a Match Official

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 2 fixtures)

2. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

MGPT 16-85

(27/10/2016)

Mark ABI-ARRAGE

Granville Rage Junior Football Club

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards or about a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3. Table B, Number 1)

Player

Offensive language towards a Match Official

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

MGPT 16-86

(22/11/2016)

Zohier BELKADI

Central Coast Futsal Club

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards or about a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3. Table B, Number 1)

2. Unsportsmanlike or unprofessional behaviour (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table C, Number 7)

3. Entering Field of Play after being sent off by a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table C, Number 9)

Coach

Offensive language towards a Match Official

Unprofessional

Entering Field of Play

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

2. Guilty

(Suspension of 4 fixtures)

3. Guilty

(Suspension of 2 fixtures)

MGPT 16-87

(16/11/2016)

Mick THORLEY

Western Wolves FC

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards or about a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3. Table B, Number 1)

2. Failure to follow any reasonable direction of an Official or Football NSW Employee or representative in relation to conduct and/or behaviour at a Match (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table C, Number 8)

Coach

Offensive language towards a Match Official

Failure to follow any reasonable direction of an Official or Football NSW Employee

1. Guilty 

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

2. Guilty

(Suspension of 2 fixtures)

MGPT 16-88

(21/11/2016)

Bradley SMITH

Western Wolves Futsal Club

1. Unauthorised entry onto the Field of Play (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table C, Number 9)

Player

Entering Field of Play

1. Guilty 

(Suspension of 2 fixtures)

MGPT 16-89

(21/11/2016)

Jesse ELLIOTT

Western Wolves FC

1. Failure to follow any reasonable direction of an Official or Football NSW Employee or representative in relation to conduct and/or behaviour at a Match (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table C, Number 8)

2. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards or about a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3. Table B, Number 1)

3. Failure to provide identifying details of an individual when reasonably requested to do so by a Match Official or Football NSW employee or representative (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table C, Number 10)

Coach

Failure to follow any reasonable direction of an Official or Football NSW Employee

Offensive language towards a Match Official

Failure to provide identifying details

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 2 fixtures)

2. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

3. Guilty

(Suspension of 4 fixtures)

MGPT 16-91

(25/11/2016)

Jamie DIB

Mountain Majik Futsal Club

1. Failure to follow any reasonable direction of an Official or Football NSW Employee or representative in relation to conduct and/or behaviour at a Match (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table C, Number 8)

2. Unsportsmanlike and unprofessional behaviour (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table C, Number 7)

3. Damaging property or equipment before, during or after a Match (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table C, Number 11)

 

Player

Failure to follow any reasonable direction of an Official or Football NSW Employee

Unprofessional

Damaging property

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 2 fixtures)

2. Guilty

(Suspension of 4 fixtures)

3. Guilty

(Suspension of 2 fixtures)

MGPT 16-92

(28/11/2016)

Peter PELEKANOS

Sydney City Eagles Futsal Club

1. Red Card for using offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards or about a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1)

2. Threatening or intimidating language or conduct towards a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 5)

3. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards or about a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3. Table B, Number 1)

4. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards or about a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3. Table B, Number 1)

Player

Red Card

Threatening or intimidating language or conduct towards a Match Official

Offensive language towards a Match Official

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 2 fixtures)

2. Guilty

(Suspension of 12 fixtures)

3. Guilty 

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

4. Guilty 

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

MGPT 16-93

(01/12/2016)

Clint PARKES

Sydney City Eagles

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards or about a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3. Table B, Number 1)

2. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards or about a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3. Table B, Number 1)

Coach

Offensive language towards a Match Official

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

2. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

MGPT 16-94

(01/12/2016)

Kane WRIGHT

West City Crusaders FC

1. Red Card for kicking a player (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table A, 'R2 Violent Conduct - Kicking')

2. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards or about a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3. Table B, Number 1)

3. Unauthorised entry onto the Field of Play (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table C, Number 9)

4. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards or about a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3. Table B, Number 1)

Player

Red Card

Offensive language towards a Match Official

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

2. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

3. Guilty

(Suspension of 2 fixtures)

4. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

MGPT 16-94

(01/12/2016)

Wittar JAJAW

West City Crusaders FC

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards or about a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3. Table B, Number 1)

Player

Offensive language towards a Match Official

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

MGPT 16-95

(06/12/2016)

Shane LACKOVIC

Sydney City Eagles

1. Unsportsmanlike or unprofessional behaviour (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table C, Number 1)

Coach

Unprofessional

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 4 fixtures)

MGPT 16-96

(06/12/2016)

Robert FOTI

Enfield Rovers Futsal Club

1. Offensive, insulting or abusive language and/or gestures towards or about a Match Official (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3. Table B, Number 1)

2. Failure to follow reasonable direction from an Official or Football NSW Employee or representative in relation to conduct and/or behaviour at a Match (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table C, Number 8)

Coach

Offensive language towards a Match Official

Failure to follow any reasonable direction of an Official or Football NSW Employee

1. Guilty 

(Suspension of 3 fixtures)

2. Guilty

(Suspension of 2 fixtures)

GPT

Reference/Party

Charge

Keywords

Outcome

GPT 16-02

Damian Briggs

Unsportsmanlike or unprofessional, Failure to provide a safe environment, Social media and detrimental public comments (Sections 15.3(d), 15.3(e) 15.3(g), 17(a) and sub-sections 17(b)(i), 17(b)(ii) and 17(b)(iii) FNSW Regulations)

 

 

Social Media Breach

Match Officials

Guilty
(16 Weeks
AFA)

GPT 16-02

Mark Cotter

Unsportsmanlike or unprofessional, Failure to provide a safe environment, Social media and detrimental public comments (Sections 15.3(d), 15.3(e) 15.3(g), 17(a) and sub-sections 17(b)(i), 17(b)(ii) and 17(b)(iii) FNSW Regulations)

 

Social Media Breach

Match Officials

Guilty
(8 Weeks AFA)

GPT 16-02

Chris Pedder

Unsportsmanlike or unprofessional, Failure to provide a safe environment, Social media and detrimental public comments (Sections 15.3(d), 15.3(e) 15.3(g), 17(a) and sub-sections 17(b)(i), 17(b)(ii) and 17(b)(iii) FNSW Regulations)

Social Media Breach

Match Officials

Guilty

(Suspension for a period of 1 month AFA)

GPT 16-08

Eddy Bosnar

 

Spitting(Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 11 FNSW Regulations)

Offensive/Insulting/Abusive language towards M/O (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1 and/or 5, Section 15.4(b) FNSW Regulations, Sections 2.1 and 2.2(c) and/or (f) FFA Code of Conduct)

 

Spitting

Offensive/Insulting Language

Match Officials

 

Not Guilty (Spitting).

Guilty. (Suspension 11 fixtures)

GPT 16-09

Aleksander Lekoski

Offensive/Insulting Language, Offensive behaviour, Intimidation of M/O (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1 and/or 5, Section 15.4(b) FNSW Regulations and Section 2.1 and 2.2(c) and/or (f) FFA Code of Conduct)

Spitting (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 11 FNSW Regulations)

Disrepute

Offensive/Insulting Language

Spitting

Match Official

Guilty. (Suspension 4 fixtures)

Not guilty. (Spitting)

GPT 16-12

Luke Nguyen

Offensive/Insulting/Abusive Language towards M/O and Punching/Kicking/Elbowing/Striking a M/O (Schedule 3 Table B, Number 1 and Table B, Number 10 FNSW Regulations)

Offensive/Insulting/Abusive Language

Punching/Striking

Match Official

Guilty. (Suspended- Life)

GPT 16-14

Matthew Hall

Disrepute, Offensive behaviour, Intimidation of M/O, Verbally or physically assaulting another person (Sections 15.4(b), (d) and (f) FNSW Regulations and/or Clause 2.1 and 2.2 (c), (f) and/or (k) FFA Code of Conduct and/or Section 7 (g) FFA National Member Protection Policy)

Offensive/Insulting Language

Match Official

 

Guilty. (Suspension 3 fixtures)

GPT 16-16

Ivan Petkovic

Offensive/Insulting language (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1 FNSW Regulations)

Offensive/Insulting Language

Match Official

Guilty. (Suspension of 3 fixtures)

GPT 16-16

Steven Bozinovski

Offensive/Insulting language (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table B, Number 1 FNSW Regulations)

Offensive/Insulting Language

Match Official

Not Guilty.

GPT 16-23

Gennadi Spivak

Breach of FFA Rules and Regulations, dual-registration (Section 15.3(b) FNSW Regulations, Schedule 3 Table C and/or Section 2.1 and 2.2(g) FFA Code of Conduct, and/or Art. 4.9(a) FFA National Registration Regulations)

Dual-registration

Unsportsmanlike/Unprofessional

Guilty. (Suspension 2 fixtures)

 

GPT 16-25

Danielle Williams

1. Unauthorised entry to the field (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table C, Number 9 FNSW Regulations.

2.Punching/Fighting (Section 15.4(d) Schedule 3, Table A, R2 FNSW Regulations)

Entering field of play

Melee

1.Guilty. (Suspension of 2 fixtures)

2. Not guilty

GPT 16-25

Hollie Wilson

1. Violent Conduct- Fighting/Kicking (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table A, R2)

Player

Red Card

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 9 fixtures)

GPT 16-25

Kellie Brown

1. Unauthorised entry to the field (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table C, Number 9)

2. Punching/fighting (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table A, R2)

Player

Red Card

Unauthorised entry to the field

 

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 4 fixtures)

2. Not guilty

GPT 16-25

Nepean FC

Failure to provide a safe enrionment, Team misconduct (Section 15.4(d), Section 16.9(b)(iv) and/or Schedule 3, Table C, Number 6; and/or Section 15.4(f) and/or (g))

Club

Misconduct- club liability

 

Guilty

(Fine of $1,000 and a bond of $1,000)

GPT 16-25

Sarah Hickling

1. Unauthorised entry to the field (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table C, Number 9)

2. Punching/fighting (Section 15.4(d), Schedule 3, Table A, R2)

Player

Unauthorised entry to the field

 

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 4 fixtures)

2. Not guilty

GPT 16-25

Southern Branch FC

1. Failure to provide safe environment, Team misconduct (Section 15.4(d), Section 16.9(b)(iv) and/or Schedule 3, Table C, Number 6)

2. Team misconduct, disrepute (Section 15.4(d), Section 16.9(b)(ii) and/or Section 15.4(f) and/or (g))

3. Failure to provide safe environment, breach of FFA rules or regulations, Offensive behaviour, Spectator violence, liability (Section 15.4(d) Schedule 3, Table C, Number 6 and/or Section 15.4(b), Sections 2.2(c), (d) and/or (e) and Sections 3.1 and 3.2 FFA Code of Conduct)

Club

Team misconduct

Offensive behaviour 

Guilty

(Fine of $2,000 and a bond of $1,000)

GPT 16-37

Emanuel ELALI

1. Accumulates eleven (11) Yellow Card in total in the Premiership, irrespective of age-grade in which they are received, must appear before the General Purposes Tribunal and must not participate in any Fixture until he or she has appeared before the General Purposes Tribunal and served in full any sanction imposed by the General Purposes Tribunal (Section 16.2(d))

Player

Accumulated eleven (11) Yellow Cards

1. Guilty

(Suspension of 4 fixtures)

AT

Reference/Party

Grounds for Appeal

Keywords

Outcome

AT 16-15

George Lundy v ESFA

Stan Stamatellis v ESFA

Steve Lawrence v ESFA

1. They were afforded a reasonable opportunity to present their case;

2. Lack of jurisdiction for both the Judiciary Committee and the Appeal Panel to hear and determine matters for an on behalf of ESFA;

3. The determination of the ESFA Judiciary Committee was affected by actual bias;

4. The determination was not reasonably open to the Judiciary Committee and the Appeal Panel;

5. Severity.

(Sections 9.3 (a)-(e)(i)-(ii) Football NSW Grievance and Disciplinary Regulations)

Definitional matters

Absence of procedural fairness

Severity

1. Upheld in regard to Mr Lundy and Mr Stamatellis

2. Rejected in regard to Mr Lawrence

AT 16-21

FNSW v Juan Arevalo;

Maurice Arevalo

 

Party not afforded a reasonable opportunity to present its case (Section 9.2(a) Football NSW Disciplinary Regulations)

 

Reasonable opportunity to present case

 

Appeal Upheld. (Remitted to the GPT for rehearing)

AT 16-31

Wollongong United FC v FSC

 

Decision not reasonable open to a Body having regards to the evidence before the Body, Severity (Section 9.3(d), (e)(v) Football NSW Disciplinary Regulations)

Reasonable opportunity to present case

Severity

Appeal upheld.

Penalty imposed was excessive.

 

AT 16-33

Albury Wodonga FA v Wangaratta City FC

Decision not reasonable open to a Body having regards to the evidence before the Body, Party not afforded a reasonable opportunity to present its case (Sections 9.3(a) and (d) Football NSW Disciplinary Regulations)

Reasonable opportunity to present case

 

AT 16-35

Yianni Fragogiannis - Sydney United 58 FC

1. The decision was one that was not reasonably open to the DC having regard to the evidence before it (Section 9.3(d) of the FNSW Regulations)

2. Severity (Section 9.3(e) of the FNSW Regulations)

Reasonable opportunity to present case

Severity

Appeal dismissed 

(Decision of the DC of 10 August 2016, being a suspension of 3 fixtures, is confirmed)

AT 16-36

Ku-ring-gai District Football Referees Association v Northern Suburds Football Association

1. The decision was one that was not reasonably open to, relevantly, a MAC having regard to evidence before the MAC (Section 9.3(d) of the FNSW Regulations)

2. Leniency (section 9.3(f) of the FNSW Regulations)

Not reasonably open to evidence before the MAC

Leniency 

Upholds the Appeal by the KDFRA from each of the determination of the NSFAAB

AT 16-40

Andrew Prentice v Football NSW

Severity (Section 9.3(e) of the FNSW Regulations)

Severity

Appeal upheld

AT 16-15

Pagewood Botany v ESFA Appeal

1. Appellants not afforded a reasonable opportunity to present their case to MAC;

2. Lack of jurisdiction for both the Judiciary Committee and the Appeal Panel to hear and determine matters for and on behalf of ESFA;

3. The determination of the ESFA Judiciary Committee was affected by actual bias;

4. The determination was not reasonably open to the Judiciary Committee and the Appeal Panel; and

5. Severity.

Jurisdiction

Not reasonably open to evidence before the MAC

Appeal upheld